Why is a crawl space damp here even without a leak?
Because Piedmont summer air holds a great deal of moisture, and the vents let it straight in. When that warm air meets the cool surfaces under a shaded house, water condenses on ducts, pipes and joists. The space can therefore get wetter on a hot dry day than on a rainy one.
This is the part that surprises people. Vents were meant to dry a space out, and in cool weather they do. In July they deliver humid air to the coldest surfaces in the building, and the result is beads of water on metal and a slow, steady damp load on the wood. No pipe has leaked and the ground may be dry.
Add an uncovered earth floor and the space has a second source, because bare soil gives up moisture continuously. That is why a ground barrier matters as much as a pump. The guide on crawl space moisture in Alamance County goes through both mechanisms in more detail.
What does a wet crawl space do to the house above it?
It keeps the subfloor and joists damp, which shows up as cupped floors, springy spots, fasteners rusting and a smell that comes up through the floor. Given long enough it supports fungal growth on the structural wood, which is the point at which the problem stops being cosmetic.
Air moves from a crawl space into the house rather than the other way, because warm air rises and the building leaks. Whatever is in the air down there, damp, spores, soil smell, ends up in the rooms above. Households often notice the smell in a closet or a hallway first, where there is less ventilation to dilute it.
The structural side takes longer but matters more. Wood held damp for months loses strength and eventually attracts decay fungi, and the parts most at risk are the sill plate and the joist ends sitting on the piers or foundation wall. Those are the hardest and most expensive things in the building to replace.
Should the vents be open or closed?
During drying they are closed, so the dehumidifier is not fighting outdoor humidity. Afterwards it depends on the house. A space with a sound ground barrier and no water intrusion often does better sealed and conditioned than vented, but that is a decision for the building, not a rule.
The traditional vented approach assumes outside air is drier than the air under the house. For a good part of a Piedmont summer it is not, and opening the vents then imports moisture. For much of the winter the opposite holds. A fixed setting cannot be right all year, which is why the question comes up on nearly every job.
What is not in doubt is the sequence. Water out, wet materials out, ground covered, drainage fixed, then a decision about ventilation or sealing. Sealing a space that still takes water simply traps it, and that mistake produces a worse space than the one it replaced.
How do you know when it is dry?
By readings on the wood, taken at the joists, the subfloor and the sill, and compared against the same materials in a part of the house that stayed dry. Appearance is no use under a house, because the space is dark, dusty and cool and everything looks the same whether it is wet or not.
A meter reading on a joist is a number that means something: it can be tracked across visits and it tells you whether the equipment is achieving anything. Crews log those numbers because a crawl space dries slowly and without a log it is impossible to say whether the last two days of equipment did any work.
The end point is the house's own baseline rather than a textbook figure. Wood in an unaffected part of the same building, at the same time of year, is what the wet material has to match. When it does, the equipment comes out, the growth cleanup is finished, and the drainage work is what remains.